1

2

3

Wealth and Want
... because democracy alone is not enough to produce widely shared prosperity.
Home Essential Documents Themes All Documents Authors Glossary Links Contact Us

 

http://www.econ.vt.edu/tideman/Tree6.pdf

Coercion Decision Tree
Do you engage in or endorse coercion?
Yes

No -- Pacifist (Peace Pilgrim)
 
Do you recognize an obligation to justify your action?
Yes

No -- Autocrat (Ivan the Terrible)

Does your justification involve claiming that you are special?
Yes
No
 
Do you claim that you are chosen?
Do you claim that you are better than others?

Does your justification involve claiming that your conception of the good is superior to that of others?
Yes --
Divine Right Monarchist
(Charles I)
Yes -- Supremacist (Hitler)
Yes -- Elitist (Lenin)
No -- You have a theory of justice

What is the most basic principle of justified coercion?

What is the most basic principle of justified coercion?

main question

answer / school of thought


secondary question

It is just to coerce people to abide by traditional rules.

Classical Conservative (Burke)

By what process does a departure from tradition acquire the respect of tradition?

It is just to coerce people to abide by what emerges from a majoritarian vote-aggregation procedure.

Majoritarian

What role do voters play?

Disinterested judges (Condorcet) --

What criteria do the judges employ?

Self-interested advocates (Welfare Economics) --

What do you do about the endless cycles of rent-seeking?

It is just to coerce people to do their parts to achieve what maximizes the sum of utilities.

Utilitarian (Bentham)

It is just to coerce people to do their parts to promote the general welfare

Good Gestaltist (DeReuter)

It is just to coerce people to abide by the rules they would have agreed to before they knew their personal circumstances.

Contractarian

What would concern people in choosing rules if they did not know their personal circumstances?

The position of the least advantaged -- Maximinist (Rawls)
Their expected utility -- Utilitarian (Harsanyi)

It is just to coerce people to provide as much for others as they have themselves.

Egalitarian

As much what?

Happiness (Roemer)
Resources (Dworkin)

It is just to coerce people to accord others the most extensive individual liberty that all can have.

Classical Liberal



People may cooperate with whom they choose to do anything that does not interfere with others. They own their bodies, and the returns to their efforts and savings

How are claims to exclusive use of natural opportunities established?

All persons have equal claims on the use of natural opportunities -- Left-Libertarian (George)
First use, the passage of time,or legal transfer of title based on these establishes ownership. -- Right-Libertarian (Rothbard)

Nicolaus Tideman.
Economics Department
Virginia Tech Blacksburg VA 24061
ntideman@vt.edu
11/7/01

To share this page with a friend: right click, choose "send," and add your comments.

Red links have not been visited; .
Green links are pages you've seen
to email this page to a friend: right click, choose "send"
   
Wealth and Want
www.wealthandwant.com
   
... because democracy alone hasn't yet led to a society in which all can prosper