Billmon waxes erudite on the so-called “Disunited State of America.”
Talk of disunion and civil war may seem like hyperbole. I’m sure it would certainly seem so to the vast majority of Americans who don’t think much about politics or culture and just want to get on with their lives. I’m sure most Spaniards felt the same way in the summer of 1936, just as most Americans did in the winter of 1860.
But the historical truth is that civil wars aren’t made by vast majorities, but by enraged and fearful minorities. Looking at America’s traditionalists and the modernists today, I see plenty of rage and fear, most, though hardly all, of it eminating from the authoritarian right. For now, these primal passions are still being contained within the boundaries of the conventional political process. But that process — essentially a system for brokering the demands of competing interest groups — isn’t designed to handle the stresses of a full-blown culture war.
Compared to most countries, America has been very lucky so far — those kind of passions have only erupted in massive bloodshed once (well, twice if you count the original revolution.) By definition, however, something that has already happened is no longer impossible. It’s easy for newspaper columnists to fantasize about disunited states, but only madmen would actually try to make them so. Unfortunately, the madmen are out there. It’s up to the rest of us to keep them under control.
It’s a given that people don’t like change: the tension is between the minority who would risk destroying the state they claim to be preserving and the more reasonable people who can navigate the shoals of progress without losing their minds.
Billmon’s European History studies went further than mine, evidently. I know a little about the Spanish Civil War as a dress rehearsal for WWII and curious fact that patriotic Americans enlisted on both sides[1][2] but the underlying themes of fear and misguided patriotism suggest some further study. For a start, this list post deserves a closer reading than I have given it so far.